Saturday, 26 November 2011

Page One: A Year Inside the New York Times - The Need for Newspapers.


For anyone interested in how their news and views are formed this film is essential. Never before has a lay audience been exposed to the challenges and crises of a world-respected newspaper like the New York Times. The biggest of these seems to be the rise of the digital news media. Anyone with access to the internet is able, like myself in writing this, to propagate their news and their views to the entire globe. So, where does this leave the traditional print media?

In an extremely confused and difficult position, the film argues. Newspapers have been slow to adjust to the revolution in communication that the internet heralded almost two decades ago. A brief glance at journalist Paul Gillin's website (http://newspaperdeathwatch.com/) is enough to convince anyone of the crisis in journalism, particularly in the US. Even the name of the website reflects the prevailing view that the days of old-school reporting are numbered. Circulation of metropolitan dailies has dropped dramatically, with the LA Times falling from a peak of 1.1 million in the mid-90s to around 600,000 in October 2010. The same publication has had to cut staff numbers correspondingly. 400 people have lost their jobs in the last ten years at this newspaper alone.

What these statistics and "Page One" point to is that this a very dangerous trend for journalism and news reporting globally. Fewer journalists on the ground will reduce news organisations' capacity to deploy reporters at the scene of world events. It will decrease the number of journalists who are able to report and interpret the news in a number of different and interesting ways, inevitably leaving the wealthier, and generally more right-wing and conservative media groups (e.g. News Corp.) able to dominate the news and therefore inform public opinion. This will be a tragedy for freedom of expression in a world that is already dominated by powerful elites and corporate interests.

"Page One" does not offer an entirely hagiographic image of The NY Times. It explores the inaccurate reporting of Judith Miller for The Times on WMD during the buildup to the Iraq War in 2003. This was part of a movement in the media that allowed the Bush Administration to garner public support for its criminal actions in the Middle East. Organisations run by human beings can never be perfect.

But we are surely a healthier and more open society for the brave coverage of The New York Times (and The Guardian in the UK) of the Wikileaks scandal. The backhanded behaviour of governments and individuals was brought into the public domain for all to see. Yes, perhaps we would inevitably have discovered this scandal without the help of newspapers. But what these institutions offer are a wealth of analysis and dedication to questioning and reporting the facts that it is impossible to guarantee from a website.

Newspapers, while sometimes failing to adhere to them, are committed to certain standards of writing and accuracy (and dare I say it, truth). If they report something falsely they can be brought to account in some way. The same cannot be said for bloggers. If something occurs in a distant corner of the world a newspaper can dispatch a professional, trained in the art of retrieving the facts and reporting them as accurately as possible. The same cannot be said for bloggers. I realise the irony of pointing this out in a blog, but that does not detract from the validity of the above statements.

Newspapers are essential in maintaining a cross section of opinion in a free culture. They bring news of whats is occurring around the globe so we do not remain isolated in our own small portion of it. "Page One" is convincing in its advocacy of the professional press. We would not expect our legal advocacy, teaching and health care to be free; someone pays for them. If we wish to continue as an open and democratic society we must also accept that we have to pay for accurate and quality reporting.

So please, buy a newspaper once in a while.