
“Had we lived I should have had a tale to tell of the hardihood, endurance and courage of my companions which would have stirred the heart of every Englishman.”
So reads Robert Falcon Scott’s final ‘Message to the Public’, written as his three remaining comrades lay about him, breathing their last as the tempest that was their undoing raged outside the thin wall of their tent. This month marks the one hundredth anniversary of the death of Scott, Edward Wilson and Henry ‘Birdie’ Bowers.
Two other members of the party had perished over the previous month; Petty Officer Edgar Evans, weakened by an old war-wound, collapsed on the march four weeks earlier, never to rise again. The second, Captain Lawrence Oates, greatly weakened by over 1000 miles of Antarctic trudge, famously sacrificed himself for his colleagues, walking out of their tent during a blizzard with the remark that he ‘may be some time’.
Scott was not, as he hoped, the first man to achieve the South Pole. Using sled dogs, a smaller team led by the Norwegian Roald Amundsen, beat Scott by over a month. Scott’s own team had made this crushing discovery having hauled their sledges for most of the route, as Scott believed that this was the way in which a gentleman ought to conduct such an endeavour.
Months of trekking resulted only in the sight of the Norwegian flag fluttering over their goal and a letter addressed to Scott asking him to verify the success of the Amundsen expedition. Three months later all five members of the British team were dead.
One hundred years on, it is not particularly important that Scott lost and Amundsen won. It is the spirit that their race embodies that is worth a moment’s thought.
These were the last two leaders of the “Heroic Age of Exploration”; men who were not motivated primarily by a quest for wealth or recognition, though it would be hard to refute the fact that these factors entered the equation at some point.
Rather, they pushed themselves forward in the service of something that was greater than themselves. For Amundsen, a man who was more adventurer than explorer, the desire to win the pole came from a burning ambition to achieve recognition for his country on the world stage. Norway had only gained independence from Sweden six years earlier, and by being the first man to penetrate the heart of the continent of Antarctica, Amundsen gained great glory for his nation.
Scott too was inspired by altruistic ambitions; his was primarily a scientific expedition, intent on gathering new data about the nature of Antarctica and the type of life that existed there, together with information concerning the origins of the continent.
The reaching of the South Pole was a secondary objective of the British expedition, that is until Amundsen threw his hat into the ring after Scott’s expedition had already set off for the Antarctic.
Scott was a man who passionately believed in the advancement of humanity as a whole, a concept that may seem outdated in the age of the individual. Even as he lay dying, his thoughts were of the example that his quest might provide to others looking to drive forward the boundaries of human achievement, ‘We are showing that Englishman can still die with a bold spirit, fighting it out to the end’ (Final letter to J.M. Barrie).
I am by no means advocating a return to the kind of patriotic fervour that enveloped the globe before two world wars, a halcyon past that haunts the dreams of David Cameron and chums, where people knew their place and were glad of it (see Downton Abbey for an example of this version of history at work).
There were many aspects of Scott’s style of leadership that leave a bitter taste in the mouth, for example his insistence that his expedition’s hut have separate sleeping quarters for officers and men, the officers’ space being noticeably more roomy. Scott was a product of the class-system that dominated Edwardian England, and though we recoil at such blatant snobbery, this was the way in which society operated at the time. We should not judge him too harshly therefore.
Differences in time and place aside, what Scott, and Amundsen’s lives can demonstrate to us, are the great feats that can be achieved when we are inspired by something that is greater than ourselves; as the poet Robert Browning wrote ‘Ah, but a man’s reach should exceed his grasp, or what’s a heaven for?’
Scott represents a spirit that calls us to challenge ourselves to achieve greatness in every sphere of our lives, for our own good and for the benefit of humankind as a whole. It is the spirit that calls us to leave what is safe and comfortable and to discover new things, consider new ideas and to change the world for the better, if only in a plethora of small ways.
In his last letter to his wife, Scott writes of having to challenge himself to do this, ‘I had to force myself into being strenuous as you know – had always an inclination to be idle’. We all, myself included, have this inclination to think that we can leave things undone for others to take up, that it matters not what we achieve for our fellow human beings and ourselves.
But Scott would argue that it is when we are ‘strenuous’ that we feel most valuable as people and achieve a deeper sense of happiness than we would otherwise know.
So Scott died in pursuit of this ideal and he was moved by it, even at the end, ‘What lots and lots I could tell you of this journey. How much better it has been than lounging in too great comfort at home. What tales you would have for the boy. But what a price to pay.’
We do not have to ship off to Antarctica to know the spirit of Scott, Amundsen and the other great explorers of the Edwardian Age, but rather we must challenge ourselves in our own lives to achieve greatness for the sake of others, and our shared humanity.